Title: |
The Myth of Repressed Memory: False Memories and
Allegations of Sexual Abuse
|
Authors: |
Elizabeth Loftus and Katherine Ketcham |
Publisher: |
St. Martin's Press, © 1994 |
St. Martin's Press
175 Fifth Avenue
New York, NY 10010
(212)674-5151
$22.95 (c)
This 290-page book brilliantly describes and then debunks the popular
myths that have resulted in the recent explosion of recovered memories
of childhood abuse. The book, which is divided into 13 chapters,
includes material from Dr. Loftus's research and the cases in which she
has been involved. Loftus and Ketcham stress that the book is about
memory, not sexual abuse, and they readily acknowledge that sexual abuse
is a serious problem. But they dispute the claim that hundreds of
thousands of women have been abused but have "repressed" the memories.
The core ideas and suggested techniques from popular survivors books are
described and Loftus describes her personal meeting with Ellen Bass, coauthor of
The Courage to Heal ()(). Stories from retractors and accused parents vividly
illustrate the harm resulting from false memories. Several actual cases are
presented in detail, including George Franklin, who was accused of murdering his
daughter's childhood friend based on the grown daughter's recovered memories,
and Paul Ingram, whose detailed confession of ritual satanic abuse (later
recanted) was based on memories recovered with the help of police interrogators. Other examples include an accused father who hired a private detective to pose
as a pseudo-client to find out what the therapist was doing and an investigative
reporter from CNN-TV who infiltrated a survivors' group and found young women
beating imagined perpetrators with rubber hoses while sitting on mattresses.
The book is easily read and understood by lay people, while providing solid
information that will be helpful to professionals. It is written in a first
person style in terms of Loftus and includes many personal accounts of her
experiences, for example, being physically attacked by her seat mate in an
airplane when the woman realized who she was: "Oh no," she said. "You're that
woman. You're that woman! And — I know this will be hard to believe
— she started
swatting me over the head with her newspaper" (p. 211).
The authors accomplish their purpose of destroying the myths about memory. It
is highly recommended for therapists, attorneys, judges, social workers, nurses,
psychologists, and anyone else who is concerned about repressed memory.
Reviewed by LeRoy Schultz, Emeritus Professor, West
Virginia University.