Title: |
Qualitative Research in Early Childhood Settings
|
Editor: |
J. Amos Hatch |
Publisher: |
Praeger Publishers, © 1995 |
Praeger
Publishers
88 Post Road West
P. O. Box 5007
Westport, CT 06881-5007
(203) 226-3571
$65 (c); $22.95 (p)
Qualitative research is being presented as an alternative to the
quantitative research methodology that has dominated social science's
research field for several generations of researchers. This book
represents a serious attempt to present the challenge of qualitative
methods to change and redirect the understanding and the research being
done in places where young children are found, i.e., day care,
preschool, and educational institutions. The editor claims the authors
are expressing "avant garde thinking." The book has two basic parts:
studies and methods, ethics and theory. There are 13 chapters; six are
qualitative studies and seven are essays that defend, clarify, and
explain qualitative research. There are 256 pages including a moderately
useful but limited index and brief descriptions of the authors of the
chapters.
The primary interest of the book is its focus on the emotional experience of
young children in the settings studied. The fundamental proposition is that our
existence is relational and social. Therefore the context of emotional
experience is necessary to understand. The method favored is the participant
observer involved in the contexts of the emotional experiences.
The book is of interest for the observations of children in their daily
settings but it fails to consider the evidence suggesting that emotion is
determined by our cognitions. The meaning ascribed to experience depends upon
the cognitive capacities of the individual. Qualitative research may provide
material for hypotheses to be developed but then quantitative research is the
only way known to ascertain what role subjective experience may have had in
producing bias and error in the observations.
Reviewed by Ralph Underwager, Institute for
Psychological Therapies.